What is the outcome when an infield fly is not caught and the runners cross home plate?

In the situation described, when an infield fly is declared but not caught, the batter is considered out, regardless of whether the ball is caught or not. This rule becomes especially relevant when runners cross home plate. According to the rules governing infield flies, while the batter is out, the runners are not forced out and can advance at their discretion.

In this case, if the runners successfully cross home plate, their runs count, as they were not put out during the play. The batter (designated as B4) is ruled out due to the infield fly rule, but it does not affect the validity of runs scored by the other runners. Therefore, while B4 is out, the runs scored by the advancing runners still count, leading to the conclusion that the correct outcome is that B4 is out, but the runs count.

Understanding this rule helps to ensure that the interpretations of infield fly situations are applied correctly, particularly in terms of scoring and the status of the runners following such a play.