What happens when a catcher throws a glove containing a lodged ball in an attempt to retire a batter-runner?

When a catcher throws their glove, which has a ball lodged in it, in an attempt to retire a batter-runner, the play is considered a deliberate act that endangers the runner. As a result, the officiating crew will call the play dead, and the batter-runner is awarded second base. This rule exists to ensure the safety of the players and maintain fair play.

The rationale behind this ruling emphasizes that throwing a glove with a ball inside it could potentially harm the runner, as it is not a traditional method of making a play. Therefore, the action is deemed inappropriate, leading to the advancement of the batter-runner to second base as a form of penalty for the infraction.

Options that involve counting strikes or making the batter-runner automatically out do not fit the situation accurately, as the incident at hand focuses on unsafe play rather than a routine strike or out scenario. No action taken until the next play does not reflect the enforcement of rules regarding safety and fair play associated with this specific situation.