Is it permissible for a state association to not use the 10-run mercy rule?

It is permissible for a state association to not use the 10-run mercy rule because state associations have the authority to establish their own rules and regulations as long as they operate within the guidelines set forth by governing bodies like the NFHS. This flexibility allows state associations to adapt rules based on the specific needs and circumstances of their member schools and their regional preferences. Thus, they can choose to implement different formats for games, including the decision to omit the mercy rule altogether if they believe it serves their players and coaches better.

On the other hand, indicating that the rule is mandatory would overlook the autonomy that states have in managing their competitions. The suggestions about team agreement or implementing a different rule imply a conditionality that is not a requirement in the context of the state's discretion and freedom to establish its own regulations. This further emphasizes the autonomy of state associations in determining the presence or absence of specific rules like the 10-run mercy rule, aligned with their operational goals and philosophies.